Starting is not completing: the degree of execution lowers the sentence by one or two degrees.
Not every stage on the way to an offence is punished alike. Articles 15 to 18 of the Spanish Criminal Code distinguish attempt, withdrawal and punishable preparatory acts (conspiracy, proposal, provocation). The degree of execution reached directly determines the sentence.
In brief. attempt (Art. 16 CP) is punished one or two degrees below the completed offence (Art. 62). Voluntary withdrawal (Art. 16.2) exempts from the attempt. Preparatory acts — conspiracy, proposal and provocation (Arts. 17-18) — are punishable only in the cases the law provides. The degree of execution is a major lever of defence.
Attempt requires a commencement of execution. The perpetrator performs all or part of the acts that should produce the result, which does not occur for reasons beyond their control (Art. 16). The sentence is reduced by one or two degrees.
Withdrawal can erase the attempt. Someone who voluntarily avoids completion or prevents the result is not punished for the attempt (Art. 16.2), except for acts already committed that themselves constitute an offence.
Preparatory acts are the exception. Conspiracy, proposal and provocation (Arts. 17-18) are punishable only where the law expressly provides, with a sentence mitigated relative to the intended offence.
| Stage | Article | Effect on sentence | Key point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Completed offence | 15 | Statutory sentence | Result produced |
| Finished attempt | 16.1 / 62 | One degree lower | All acts performed |
| Unfinished attempt | 16.1 / 62 | Two degrees lower | Partial acts |
| Voluntary withdrawal | 16.2 | Exemption from attempt | Free renunciation |
| Conspiracy | 17 | Mitigated sentence | Cases provided by law |
| Proposal | 17 | Mitigated sentence | Cases provided by law |
| Provocation | 18 | Mitigated sentence | Public incitement |
| Simple preparatory acts | — | Not punishable | Outside statutory cases |
Indicative elements based on the Spanish Criminal Code. The reduction depends on the inherent danger and the degree of execution reached. This overview does not replace a lawyer’s analysis.
Qualifying the attempt reduces the sentence. Distinguishing a finished from an unfinished attempt, or establishing a voluntary withdrawal, lowers the sentence by one or two degrees — or erases it for the attempt.
We examine each act performed. The exact point where execution stopped, the spontaneity of the renunciation and the real suitability of the means used determine punishability and sentence.
People accused of an uncompleted offence whose degree of execution is disputed.
People who voluntarily prevented the result and invoke withdrawal.
Participants in a collective attempt whose roles must be distinguished.
Relatives seeking to understand the impact of the degree of execution.
Speak to a criminal lawyer
Criminal defence in English before the courts of Alicante and the rest of Spain, for residents and for visitors who have flown home.